Fluoride varnish concentration gradient and its effect on enamel demineralization.

PURPOSE Two of the 4 fluoride varnishes available on the American market today are sold in 10-mL tubes of 5% NaF varnish (Duraphat and Duraflor). Pilot studies have shown that a separation of contents within these tubes exists. The purpose of the current study was 4-fold: (1) to measure the fluoride concentration gradient in 10-mL tubes of fluoride varnish, based on resting position of the tube prior to use; (2) to compare and contrast fluoride concentration gradients of Duraphat, Duraflor, and CavityShield; (3) to compare this gradient to the ability to inhibit caries in an artificial caries environment; and finally, (4) to determine if quantitative light fluorescence (QLF) can detect differences in lesions developed when exposed to an artificial caries environment and fluoride varnish. METHODS Human teeth specimens were subjected to a caries challenge and treated with a sample of fluoride varnish from 1 of 5 categories: Duraphat stored horizontally and vertically for 1 week, Duraflor stored horizontally and vertically for 1 week, or a CavityShield 0.4 mL "unidose." All specimens were then analyzed with the QLF system and with confocal microscopy. RESULTS Results showed no significant fluoride ppm differences exist between groups (P=.29). It was shown that the order in which Duraflor varnish was dispensed from tubes significantly affected the fluoride concentration (P<.05). The order effect was not significant for Duraphat (P=.99). QLF data analysis showed there was no significant difference (P>.05) in the amount of remineralization obtained by using any varnish stored in any position. CONCLUSIONS These results indicate that all 3 brands of fluoride varnish are able to remineralize incipient in vitro carious lesions, regardless of what part of the 10-mL tube the varnish is taken from. However, a fluoride concentration gradient exists in tubes of Duraflor. Also, QLF is able to detect demineralized and remineralized incipient lesions.